Our Editors Shared the 10 Target Products They Would Add to Their Own Hall of Fame, and Prices Start at Just $10

PEOPLE editors and writers know their way around Target. Not only are they great at finding deals, but they also know the products worth buying over and over again. And they’re no longer gatekeeping that information.

We polled the team to find out what Target finds they’d add to their personal hall of fame, and as expected, they came through. Their recommendations include a “Mary Poppins bag,” throw pillows that feel “high-end,” and skincare that provides “hours of moisture.” Plus, the list starts at just $10.

Editor-Favorite Target Finds

• Prequel Half & Half Peptides + Ceramides Fluid Moisturizer, $22 (orig. $26)
• Fragrance Fave: Being Frenshe Cashmere Vanilla Eau De Perfume, $30
• “Moisture for Hours”:Eos Shea Better Vanilla Cashmere Moisture Body Lotion, $10
• A New Day Sandy Mule Flats, $29
• Threshold Oversized Blocked Woven Square Throw Pillow, $30
• Add a Glow: Threshold Cantilever Drop Pendant Swing Arm Floor Lamp, $125
• Threshold Designed with Studio McGee Marble Catchall Tray, $18
• Roomy “Mary Poppins” Bag: Universal Thread Oversized Slouchy Shoulder Bag, $35
• Threshold Textured Faux Fur Reversible Throw Blanket, $25
• Casaluna Reflection Core Linen Spray, $10

Prequel Half & Half Peptides + Ceramides Fluid Moisturizer

I’ve tried dozens upon dozens of skincare products and this fluid moisturizer from Prequel is something I recently picked up after seeing it all over my social media pages. It’s such an amazing alternative to pricier brand’s face milks, and my ultra-dry and sensitive skin has never felt more touchably soft and hydrated. It’s amazing under makeup too. — Ali Faccenda, Associate Editor

Being Frenshe Cashmere Vanilla Eau De Perfume

Not to brag, but I’m a prof at finding the best perfumes, especially fragrances that are affordable. This cashmere vanilla scent from Ashley Tisdale’s Target brand is one that I get the most compliments on from friends and the first one I recommend when anyone is looking for a new option to add to their collection. For only $30, I’ll be a lifelong fan of this product as long as it exists. — Ali Faccenda, Associate Editor

Eos Shea Better Vanilla Cashmere Moisture Body Lotion

I was looking for a new body lotion last year and stumbled upon this after a recommendation from my cousin. I wasn’t familiar with Eos beyond its circular lip balms, and I was pleasantly surprised by the brand’s offerings. This moisturizer smells like a delicious dessert without being overpowering, and it offers hours of hydration thanks to the shea butter. Plus, I love layering the decadent scent with perfume. At only $10, you cannot go wrong with this. — Jackie Tempera, Writer

A New Day Sandy Mule Flats

My mom bought these shoes for me in the now-sold out cream color, but I’m eyeing them in black, too, because they are super comfortable for walking. The buckle adds a nice accent to the otherwise plain shoe, and it’s easy to wear with lots of outfits year-round. — Jackie Tempera, Writer

Threshold Oversized Blocked Woven Square Throw Pillow

I’ve been searching for throw pillows forever, until I came across this oversized block style at Target. Despite its $30 price tag, the pillow looks and feels high-end with a textured woven front and linen-like back. The blocked design pops in person without being too overwhelming, and it was bigger than I expected — perfect for sectionals. I’ve been thinking about grabbing some for my bedroom, too. — Destinee Scott, Writer

Threshold Cantilever Drop Pendant Swing Arm Floor Lamp

Since I can’t buy everything from Restoration Hardware, I’m always on the hunt for affordable yet high end-looking accents to elevate my space — like this floor lamp. Its telescope-inspired design adds a nautical, utilitarian touch to my living room while providing warm light. I’d buy it again in a heartbeat for $125. — Destinee Scott, Writer

Threshold designed with Studio McGee Marble Catchall Tray

I have expensive taste but a Target budget, and these marble trays from Shea McGee’s collection are scattered all over my home. They’re so weighty and intricate, and my guests always comment that they look like vintage grails (they’re shocked when I tell them the price). This piece adds such a luxe yet neutral touch to my entryway table, where I use it as a catch-all tray for keys and spare change. — Olivia Cigliano, Writer

Universal Thread Oversized Slouchy Shoulder Bag

This faux suede tote has been at the front of my handbag rotation for six months. It’s a practically bottomless Mary Poppins bag for work and travel, and its high end-looking design instantly elevates any outfit I pair it with. It holds my laptop, a spare sweater, and small essentials with room to spare, and I love that its long shoulder strap fits over my bulky winter coats. Plus, it’s not too big that it overwhelms my 5-foot frame. — Olivia Cigliano, Writer

Threshold Textured Faux Fur Reversible Throw Blanket

I always run cold. As such, I have a bit of an obsession with throw blankets. This Threshold blanket was given to me as a Christmas gift this year, and it has become my new favorite. While the faux fur design keeps me cozy when I’m watching TV, I also throw it on top of my comforter at night for added warmth. The reversible design is a fun touch and makes it super versatile to place over any piece of furniture when it isn’t wrapped around me. — Michelle Baricevic, Writer

Casaluna Reflection Core Linen Spray

I’m a terrible sleeper. Most nights, my brain just won’t shut off, and I’m lucky if I can get even an hour of shut-eye. Lately, though, this room and linen spray from Casaluna has helped me get a better night’s rest. It’s formulated with notes of cashmere, coconut, lavender, patchouli, and shea flower to infuse rooms with a calming scent that’s said to promote tranquility. I’ve been spraying it directly on my pillows before  bed, and I have noticed a difference in my overall sleep pattern. — Michelle Baricevic, Writer