My Current Loafers Were So Painful, I Scoured the Internet for a New Pair — and Found 5 Comfy Styles

Last year, I found the perfect pair of lug sole loafers that I was sure I would wear regularly. And while the style looks good with nearly every outfit, they’re not nearly as comfortable as they are stylish. 

I decided to do my research this time around and scour Walmart’s shopper reviews to find a pair of loafers that I could actually walk in — and that wouldn’t cause blisters. Fortunately, Madden NYC, No Boundaries, and Time and Tru have customer-approved styles that tick every box. Ahead, you’ll find the top 5 styles on my own wish list, and they’re all less than $30.

Best Loafers at Walmart

Madden NYC Platform Lug Sole Loafers

These Madden NYC platform loafers look almost identical to the uncomfy pair that I already own. And considering the style was never the problem (just the constant blisters), these are at the top of my wishlist. Shoppers confirmed that they’re comfortable enough to walk in, and added that the quality and price tag are just as impressive. Plus, the slip-on style makes them easy to toss on as you’re headed out the door, while the comfort foam insoles are what gives the shoes that extra cushioning. 

No Boundaries Platform Penny Loafers

If you want even more height from your shoes, this No Boundaries style is the ideal pick. The 2.62-inch block heel elevates the style, and the front platform ensures that they’re still comfortable even with the height. The design also features a memory foam footbed, which shoppers praised. Nearly every five-star review mentioned how comfortable the loafers fit. 

Time and Tru Faux Leather Penny Loafers

Time and Tru’s faux leather penny loafers offer a classic look. The style, which comes in both black and brown hues, makes for an excellent everyday shoe — whether you’re heading to the office or dinner out. They slip on easily and are made from a flexible faux leather that doesn’t feel too constricting. In fact, you can even wear the style with socks if you’re looking to keep warm in the winter. 

Time and Tru Velvet and Metallic Penny Loafers

Time and Tru also has a similar penny loafer style featuring edgier materials. They’re offered in winter-ready velvet and a sleek and modern metallic. The material has just the right amount of give to make them easy to walk in, while also providing support. According to shoppers, the footbed is cushy and comfortable. One customer noted that they look just like an expensive pair but for a fraction of the price, while another said they have quality to match.

Madden NYC Chain Loafers

These brown faux suede loafers have a perfect rating thanks to their luxe-looking material that fits even better than high fashion versions, according to one shopper. The flat style feels classic and timeless, while the chain detailing adds a contemporary edge. And the sole is plush and flexible, so you can easily wear them all day.

Head over to Walmart to snag a comfortable pair of loafers from Time and Tru, Madden NYC, and No Boundaries while sizes are still in stock..