Megan Hilty Tearfully Says Goodbye to Death Becomes Her as She Takes Final Bow in Broadway Hit

The Lunt-Fontanne Theatre in New York City was overflowing with love on Sunday, Jan. 11, as Megan Hilty played her final performance in Broadway’s Death Becomes Her.

PEOPLE was in the crowd for the milestone matinee, alongside a number of Hilty’s closest supporters and members of the musical’s creative team, including director/choreographer Christopher Gattelli and Julia Mattison, who penned the score with Noel Carey.

Throughout the afternoon, Hilty was showered with praise from the audience, even receiving extended cheers for her entrance. Her ACT I showstopper, “Falling Apart,” earned her a rare mid-show standing ovation.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.  

But it was during the curtain call that Hilty actually fell apart. Taking her bow, she immediately teared up and continued to cry as everyone in the house — including her castmates — surrounded her with applause.

“We are all obviously here to celebrate the one and only Megan Hilty,” costar Josh Lamon said, giving the actress her flowers (while handing her a literal bouquet).

“I tried to think of something to say and the one word that kept coming to mind is ‘extraordinary,’ he continued. “Megan you are an extraordinary, actress, comedian, human. You are not just our lead, you are our leader. Anybody who has come into this building you lift up, you cheer on.

Lamon went on to share his admiration for Hilty, continuing to call her “an extraordinary artist.” He also called her “an extraordinary mother,” noting especially that she parented her kids (daughter Viola Philomena, 11, and son Ronan Laine, 7 — both of whom she shares with husband Brian Gallagher) all “while leading a show.”

“We love you to the moon and this is not goodbye; this is a celebration,” Lamon said.

After hugging Lamon, Hilty continued to cry, her costars Michelle Williams and Dee Roscioli offering her comfort. As the curtain came down, Hilty waved and blew kisses to the crowd. She ended her time on stage jumping in celebration with her cast.

Hilty originated the part of the glamorous, immortal Madeline Ashton in both the show’s 2024 Chicago premiere and its Broadway run, earning her second Tony nomination, this time for Best Leading Actress in a Musical. She’s been attached to the project since its early development in 2023.

Broadway favorite Betsy Wolfe, a Tony nominee herself for her powerhouse turn in & Juliet, will step into the role of Ashton beginning Friday, Jan. 16.

After the 2025 Tony Awards in June, Hilty took a four-week absence, to recover “from a vocal injury that only time can heal,’ calling her work in the musical “the most challenging and rewarding role” she has “ever taken on.” The actress later returned to show in July.

Based on Robert Zemeckis’ beloved 1992 Universal Pictures dark comedy, Death Becomes Her has become a smash hit on Broadway, scoring 33 nominations across the 2024–2025 theater season — including 10 Tony nods — and delighting audiences with its drop-dead hilarious take on vanity and fame.

Starring alongside Hilty is three-time Tony nominee Jennifer Simard, who plays Madeline’s frenemy Helen Sharp. They’re joined by two-time Tony nominee Christopher Sieber — as Ernest Menville, the man Madeline and Helen fight over — and Grammy Award winner Williams, as the mysterious Violet Van Horn.

Their roles were originated on screen by Meryl Streep, Goldie Hawn, Bruce Willis and Isabella Rossellini, respectively.

Tickets to Death Becomes Her are now on sale.